How do you know you’re called to preach—and how do you grow into that calling?
Recorded at the Expositors Collective training event at Reliance Church in Temecula, California, this live Q&A brings together Bob Franquiz, Ted Leavenworth, Pilgrim Benham and Faith Wake, with Mike Neglia moderating. Their answers move from the ethics of AI in sermon preparation to the deeply human work of finding a mentor, receiving feedback and learning to teach the people in front of you.
Can AI help a preacher without doing the formative work of study and reflection for them? Should a sense of calling be confirmed by others? Where does a new Bible teacher find someone willing to help? And why does leading an interactive study require a different kind of preparation from delivering a sermon?
The panel offers candid stories, practical counsel and a few laughs along the way. They also discuss how to ask questions that invite participation, handle a wrong answer graciously, and decide whether a manuscript, an outline or a mixture of both best serves the message.
Resources mentioned
AI Shepherds and Electric Sheep: Leading and Teaching in the Age of Artificial Intelligence — Sean O’Callaghan and Paul A. Hoffman
https://bakeracademic.com/products/9781540968012_ai-shepherds-and-electric-sheep
Listen further on Expositors Collective
The Heart of a Mentor: Walking with Someone Today to Shape Tomorrow — Danny Ramos, episode 451
https://podcasts.apple.com/ch/podcast/the-heart-of-a-mentor-walking-with-someone/id1397572249?i=1000791052917
Observation, Interpretation, Application: How to Study the Bible with Bryan Stupar — episode 447
https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/observation-interpretation-application-how-to-study/id1397572249?i=1000785680938
Innovation Meets Integrity: AI and the Preacher’s Calling — Dr Paul Hoffman
https://open.spotify.com/episode/4Fsx7d2iGUXh2oUcQOnyYG?si=9157ccf1a9144cac
The Perils and Possibilities of ChatGPT for Preachers — Nick Cady and Mike Neglia
https://open.spotify.com/episode/2oTViQSw1a641dsMqfyMOO?si=6f3cc77c796d4174
Expositors Collective equips, encourages and mentors preachers and Bible teachers to grow in their personal study and public proclamation of God’s Word.
https://expositorscollective.org/
Expositors Collective is part of Calvary Chapel Cooperative, a family of ministries working together to strengthen churches and support faithful leaders.
[00:00:00] You can be called to do something and stink at it. And so those are not incongruous ideas. So you don't get your gifting in final form. You get your gifting in raw form. And then you take that gift and you fan it into flame, as Paul told Timothy. Hey, welcome to the Expositors Collective Podcast, episode 459. I'm your host, Mike Neglia. And the voice that you just heard is that of Bob Franquiz.
[00:00:29] He's senior pastor of Calvary Fellowship in Miramar, Florida. Bob was one of the panelists at our most recent Preachers Training Event or Bible Teacher Equipping Weekend, which took place in Temecula, California. In this panel, Bob is joined by Ted Leavenworth, senior pastor at Reliance, Pilgrim Benham, dean of students at Calvary Chapel Bible College in Florida.
[00:00:59] And Faith Wake, who is a worship leader, who is a creative, and she was one of our group leaders for the Time Together at Expositors Collective. She led one of our women's groups. So together, we are going to take questions about AI, mentorship, recognizing a call to ministry, and the ins and outs of leading an interactive Bible study. And how that is different to a monologue in a way.
[00:01:29] So I hope this conversation helps you grow in your personal study and public proclamation of God's Word. So the most upvoted question on here was from the first session, and it was asking if everyone could share their first time ever teaching from the Bible. And you know what? They've all answered those questions already.
[00:01:56] And you can find all of them on the Expositors Collective podcast. Actually, not Faith. I'll get it. Yeah. But I just want to do a plug for the Expositors Collective podcast. So again, it's kind of a deep dive, long form conversations about all aspects of sermon preparation and delivery, and then also the personal stories of the people that are there.
[00:02:15] So with that being said, I'm not going to ask that question. I'm going to send you to go find it. And at the end of this, we're going to send out an email. And I'm going to find interviews with all of our speakers. So if you want to know more about them and learn more from them, you can find that specific episode. Okay. What are your thoughts on the use of AI in sermon preparation or Bible study preparation? It's a very relevant, ongoing conversation that we're having.
[00:02:46] I was waiting for that in sermon prep essentials. I thought that was going to be you. Yeah. I'm not a big AI. I use AI for everything. You can ask my wife. We'll be talking about something. I'm like, oh, let me ask a friend. And then she'll say, what did your friend say? But I don't use a lot of AI in sermon prep.
[00:03:07] When I was doing my dissertation at Liberty, we would get these emails that they would say, if you use AI in the writing of your dissertation, you will be expelled and never allowed to return. So anyway, I was just, I never used it. And every time I opened it, even during my, I felt like I was committing a crime.
[00:03:27] So I didn't use it. I do. The only time I did use it for my dissertation, I would ask it, give me three scholars who believe this particular view. But then again, it's not always right. Because it would say like, oh, this is what Craig Keener thinks. I'd be like, Craig Keener doesn't think that. Like, you're right, Bob. I was mistaken. I misunderstood. Like, you didn't misunderstand. Right.
[00:03:50] You just don't know. And so anyway, that's why I don't, you know, John Connor said to not trust the machines. So I don't know. Maybe we should. I knew what he was talking about. I find AI helpful after I've finished my notes. I'll copy them, paste them and ask for help generating questions. Because we have sermon-based studies that we do during the week.
[00:04:17] And so if you attend here, you know that we'll put questions up, a slide with questions at the end. So to generate those questions, I will enlist AI's help. And what it then does is it assimilates questions based on the notes, the input that we put in it. So there's an example of a good way to use AI. And so I do that, and it's very helpful. Yes, it's kind of funny. So I was texting my wife literally a minute ago.
[00:04:46] And she, I must have responded really thoughtfully because she said, did you use AI? And I said, why would you think that? She said, you were, it was just very thoughtful and long. And I was like, wait a minute. So I went into Claude and I said, tell my wife I love and miss her. And then it said, hey, babe, just wanted you to know I love and miss you. So I sent her a screenshot of that and she thought that was hilarious. No, I think that this is a danger. I see it in Bible college.
[00:05:13] We've had some students who have, you know, just, well, I just wanted to make, you know, some grammatical changes. But then I guess with Grammarly, you can even say make the sound better. And so they're unaware sort of that that that can actually get you expelled. So I think I think very cautiously we should not be ever putting in something that's not we should never be preaching something that's not an original thought.
[00:05:38] Right. So maybe a generation ago or 20 years ago, the temptation was to steal Driscoll's illustrations and just preach like Driscoll. At least some of us did that. Now it's just pump in, you know, some intel into chat and then just preach that. So I would just say avoid it, steer clear of it, just like you wouldn't plagiarize another sermon word for word. You would never hopefully do that with chat as well. So I think it makes sense as a research tool, but certainly not something that's writing sermons for you.
[00:06:08] Right. And if my use of AI is bypassing any opportunity to connect with a person, to ask them for a story, ask them for to look over my notes or whatever, then don't do it. But also if AI is bypassing the work that God wants to do in me to sit with a thought for God knows how long, to walk with it, to touch some grass, when I can just go to AI and type it in, then don't do it. Don't bypass the process of connection with others and with God. Thank you.
[00:06:39] Yeah, thank you. And then forgive me for doing this two times in a row, but I would point you towards the Expositors Collective podcast. We did two episodes on this back to back. And actually, this was like last year. It's probably worth revisiting since this is such a live ethical conversation and preachers are so interested in this. But I'll include a link to that in the email.
[00:07:01] But Sean O'Callaghan and Paul Hoffman wrote a book called AI Shepherds and Their Digital Sheep. And it's just like it's like 200 pages thinking through, I guess, what does it mean to be a human? What are the ethics? What does it mean to use non-human technology in Christian ministry? And they come down very similar as we've heard from the panel.
[00:07:27] They're not the biggest fans of it, but they kind of show us the work and the thinking process that leads up to that instead of simply a gut reaction against it. Like, ooh, it feels yucky, so I don't like it. It's like they kind of build the case for that. And so I got to interview Paul Hoffman, and it's one of the more downloaded episodes that we have put out. But someone's asking, are there any mentorship resources for me as a student?
[00:07:56] So obviously somebody heard Danny Ramos this morning speaking about that. And maybe there's the thought of like, yeah, okay, well, how do I do that? So I think if you remember this morning, which feels like a week and a half ago, Danny talked about how somebody came up to him and said, how do I do that? And then now essentially someone's kind of pointing to Danny and say, how do I get one of those? How do I get somebody like that in our lives? How do we find a mentor? I think the first thing is just taking on a teaching responsibility.
[00:08:26] I'll tell you this. I've never heard someone's first preaching story as, man, I got up there, killed it, couldn't wait for the next one. Usually it's got up there, it killed me. And then I question whether I could do this at all. And, you know, so being a good preacher generally means doing it poorly for a little while. But, you know, the guys that I mentor on our staff are guys that are doing it.
[00:08:55] So, you know, we're not mentoring guys for like hypothetical things that may or may not happen. It's guys that are going to have a teaching responsibility or have a teaching coming up. So I would say the very first thing you want to do is take on a teaching responsibility and then talk to your pastor, one of your pastors, and say, hey, I'm going to teach this thing. Could you help me not stink? Yeah. Was it Guzik who said, take your first five years of messages, just get them out of the way as quick as you can? Yeah.
[00:09:24] He said your first 200 sermons are going to stink. Yeah. So, yeah, burn through them as fast as you can. Okay, 200. So, yeah. So essentially he would say yes. Say yes to every opportunity. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. For those of you that preached your first sermon today, you got 199 before they start getting good. Yeah. Relationship. If you're looking for a mentor, it starts with a relationship. And that relationship starts with you getting involved in the ministry.
[00:09:51] And so that's where you start. You start with a relationship. And, you know, it involves showing up. It involves serving. It involves, you know, to use the, you know, Karate Kid metaphor, the wax on, wax off moments that seem completely worthless and meaningless, and they're not. So I would say that's where it starts. I feel like we kind of don't know.
[00:10:21] We kind of choose our mentors. So, you know, if you go to the gym and some flabby guy comes up to you and is like, here, let me show you how to do it, Sonny. You know what I mean? Like, you're not going to be like, oh, cool. Let me follow this guy. So I think sometimes we. I told you that was a mistake that day. You wouldn't leave me alone. It was awkward. So I think we choose. So maybe inadvertently we have mentors that we, because of technology, we follow online.
[00:10:51] We want to emulate. And I know, talk more to this later, finding your own voice. That's key. But I think, like, for me anyway, it was what Danny invited us to do, literally ask. And my pastor said, I'll pray about it, not sure. You know, and then eventually he took the time to disciple me. But, yeah, I think a lot of times it's not on the job of the mentor, but it's on our part to seek out someone that we are inspired by.
[00:11:19] And, like, will you take the time, even if it's, you know, digitally, like, to help me grow. How did you know that you were called to teaching or preaching? Well, for me, I had been a Christian for about three weeks. And I was at a Wednesday night Bible study. We started, my wife and I, we came to know the Lord at the same time.
[00:11:49] And we were at Calvary Chapel before Lauderdale. And Bob had gotten done teaching a message, an invitation. And I just felt God, this is probably one of the first times I ever felt God speak to me and say, that's what you're going to do. And that really, you know, supernatural call is what made me apply to the Bible college, of which I was such a terrible student in school.
[00:12:17] It took me three semesters before I actually filled out the application because I was so embarrassed when I had to write that it took me five years to graduate high school. And then I got okay with it because now I just tell people, like, I stayed a little extra, really wanted to make sure everything sunk in. And so, but at first I was so embarrassed by it that I got through, I got the application, started filling it out, and then I would throw it away. Like, there's no way they're going to accept me. And then I started again. Anyway, it was after almost a year.
[00:12:46] The third application is the one that I filled out. Turned out they'll accept anybody. And so, we had to see if your application is still in the paperwork. So anyway, but it really, for me, once again, it started out with what I felt was a real call from the Lord and then the call to be trained to be able to do it. Because you can be called to do something and stink at it.
[00:13:14] And so, those are not incongruous ideas. So, you don't get your gifting in final form. You get your gifting in raw form. And then you take that gift and you fan it into flame, as Paul told Timothy. Also, I think it's because people also keep asking you to teach. People keep asking you to teach. That's a good sign that you may be called to it. But also, that your love for the people you're teaching grows. And that you weep for them.
[00:13:44] That you care so deeply about them. That's how you know you're called to do it. But also, the opposite is also true. If you start to hate and become embittered to the people that you're teaching, maybe it's time to take a break. Maybe you're burnt out a little bit. Maybe God needs to teach you something a little bit. Yeah. Yeah, I was going to say a similar thing. If you're getting invitations, that's a good indicator.
[00:14:11] Yeah, so my natural disposition in school was not ever to be in front of anyone. I was incredibly, like the shyest kid in my class, in the school maybe, even in the world. I don't know. I was very shy. And so, getting up on stage, it's not a natural disposition for me. I can kind of be an introvert. So, for me, it was not like, oh, of course he's called. For me, it was some people gave me an opportunity to lead like a high school Sunday school.
[00:14:39] And the feedback I got from the leadership was, wow, like that was disproportionately good based on what we know of you, never talking. And so, I think… Did you get that from me, AI? So, I think for me, it was then presenting that to the elders of the church and just sort of seeking their feedback. If they were to say, we don't sense a call on your life, then I'd be like, sweet, no worries.
[00:15:02] But once the leadership, the elders especially, are like, man, there is a definite call, then it's kind of up to them to cultivate that, I believe, to cultivate that gifting and stir that up and strengthen that. But I think it starts there. Yeah, I run in kind of different Christian circles. You know, I'm a Calvary Chapel guy. I got broad friends. I read broadly. And I've noticed within our Calvary Chapel world, called often is an internal sense.
[00:15:31] And I've noticed in my other Christian friends, call oftentimes is kind of an external invitation. And I think there's value in both of these. I think that it can be a little bit dangerous if it's just kind of up to us to determine or decide or proclaim or announce, I'm called to this, without someone else kind of recognizing or inviting that. And so, I'm hearing both of those and just kind of wanted to highlight that.
[00:15:57] But today at lunch, I had a great conversation with somebody talking about how they're wondering, they're feeling kind of a call to pastoral ministry. And so, rather than just kind of keeping that interior, they brought that to the elders, the pastor of their church. Hey, what do you think? I think that's a really healthy thing. It doesn't all stay in here, but also needs to be recognized externally as well.
[00:16:21] How does, I guess, preparing and delivering like a, I guess, quote unquote, like a sermon vary from preparing and delivering like an interactive Bible study? So, most of what we're talking about has to do with like delivering monologues, proclaiming. But what some of us are involved in right now is like leading interactive Bible studies. How do you study for those?
[00:16:47] I think you study similarly, but the deliveries are completely different. So, you have to, I mean, I have a horrible story, embarrassing story. Do tell. Well, I had put together a message that, you know, was for preaching. It happened to be a message that was the second message I ever preached, which was only slightly better than the first.
[00:17:15] And, and both were actually recorded on videotape. And, and the videotape of one of them was around when I was planting this church. And I saw, I saw some, I saw some of my guys actually drooling over getting their hands on that tape. And I destroyed the tape before anybody could get their hands on it. Just saying tape puts it into perspective of when it was. It was a VHS tape. Yeah. Yeah. And Ted, you think it's destroyed.
[00:17:45] Actually, guys, can you roll it now? Yeah. We've actually. No, I got it destroyed. But I, but I had preached that message. My point is I had preached that message and it was horrible. My mom liked it. Um, but then I was invited to give, uh, to give that the same study, um, in a, in a firefighters gathering. Cause I was in the fire department at the time and I got to the firefighters gathering and
[00:18:14] there was, it was a lunch or a breakfast gathering. There were six of us there and I presented it the same way as I had presented it before, you know, a church of 150 people. And, uh, and it was awkward. It was horrible. And nobody told me that that's not what you should do and how you should do it. So, yeah. Cool story. This person's asking what they should do. So you're saying, yeah.
[00:18:42] So you're saying that the delivery certainly differs and matters. Um, yeah, but like for what? Okay. So you, so you gave the clue in saying, um, you know, one is a monologue format. So if you're, if you're in a setting where it's, it's a church service, that's a monologue format. We're not discussing it. We're not taking Q and a, um, in a home Bible study, that's a dialogue format.
[00:19:09] And so in a dialogue format, you, you, you need to really put more of your emphasis into questions, um, and drawing people into discussion and union. And the temptation in that is that we're, we're uncomfortable with long silence, long silence and long pauses. Get comfortable with those. Ask the question, let it lay there like a dead fish and, and get people, you know, talking
[00:19:39] and maybe even prime the pump by having, um, a couple of, you know, two or three easy questions, easy response questions, and make sure that they're compound question, not, not a yes or no question. If you're asking a yes or no question, you're not getting a dialogue out of that. So that's, that's a few things. There's lots more that we could say. So I think the inductive Bible study that we learned last night is very helpful there. So including the people and having someone else read the scripture.
[00:20:08] Uh, okay, now let's spend a minute observing it. You can have some observation questions, bring them into that. Interpret. Okay. Now let's, let's walk through this. Here's some, here's three big ideas that I've seen. What else do you guys see? Uh, instead of just presenting the three ideas. Uh, and then it's actually super fun to say, okay, so we could look at this section of David and Goliath from a man center point of view and then lay it out for them. How can we see, like we did last night, how can we see Christ displayed in a better way? Uh, and then just kind of guide them in.
[00:20:35] It actually can be more exciting, uh, to be a part of something like that. I find that I almost need to prepare more for discussion based Bible study than I do for like sermon preparation or teaching preparation because of those right field, left field, I don't know, baseball field questions that come out of nowhere or answers that are like, Ooh, that is theologically so wrong. Um, so I need to be prepared, more prepared for those versus a monologue type teaching where I'm teaching and I'm like, that's it. No more discussion.
[00:21:05] Let's leave and worship. Um, so I, you almost need to prepare for the, you know, the kid in the black hoodie in the back zipped up doesn't want to engage. You want to prepare for those to somehow engaging them and, and then how to even shepherd the person who's just dominating the conversation. So there's personalities. You also have to be more aware of versus when you're teaching is just like, here it is. So yeah, know your audience. Gary Breshears has a great technique. He says, let's hear from a different voice, you know?
[00:21:35] And so we always have somebody who's dominating the conversation. Let's hear from a different voice. And then something else too, is that sometimes the people have the most insightful things to say, don't talk. And so, uh, so get comfortable calling on people and asking them to be involved. Yeah. Yeah. Um, our church hosts a, like a Monday night interactive Bible study that is, it's essentially an addiction recovery group. So lots of people from really rough backgrounds processing things.
[00:22:05] And I'm not there all the time. Like there's somebody else from that community who leads it most of the time, but the times that I do it, it is exhausting. It is, it is, I agree with you, Faith. It is so much harder than, than the monologue thing, uh, because anyone could say anything and they do. And it's, it's actually quite, and, and I, I correct people like every single time. And there's like an art and a science to like correcting somebody because of them. And then also you're, you're calculating.
[00:22:34] It's like, okay, well, they made an error about this, but nobody caught it. And so it's not worth correcting, but then sometimes they, they make an error on close to like something that's actually quite important. And how can you correct that for the benefit of the others while also affirming the person? So they come back next week. So it's, it's challenging. I've, I found what, what I say more Mondays than not is like, Hey, I got good. I got good news for you. What you said is incorrect, but guess what? The truth is actually even better.
[00:23:04] And then, and here's the truth and it's a way of affirming them. And then everyone's kind of naughty and I'm like, okay, good. It worked. Let's try again next time. That's a freebie. Last question. And this is trying to end a little bit earlier as we kind of head into the next thing is, what do your notes look like? Outline or manuscript? This is a question. Also, it came up during a lunch conversation. I manuscript. Oh yeah. You said that. Yeah. For searchability later. Cause I want the searchability.
[00:23:33] And then the other thing that I do, it's a, it's in a pages document. And, uh, my points are in blue. Um, funny illustrations are in red. Just a regular illustration. It's not necessarily funny as in green. What about non-funny? Non-funny is green. Okay. And, um, so then, um, other scriptures are in yellow or orange. I used to be yellow. Now it's orange because I'm older and it's harder to read.
[00:24:02] And, um, but yeah, so that way I color code so that when I'm not really always looking at the notes, I can just see what color is coming up and I know, I know where I'm, where I'm going. Yeah. I manuscript, uh, one time, I don't know if my iPad wasn't working. I knew what I was teaching. So I kind of stepped away from the manuscript and my congregation said like, that was one of the best sermons you've ever preached. And so I was like, oh, so I tried it the next week.
[00:24:31] We've got in the pulpit, no notes. And it was the worst sermon I'd ever preached. So, um, yeah, I, I literally just manuscript everything out to the detail. Um, and for me, that's, that's, I, you know, you try different things and it fits like Saul's armor. So, um, that you'll kind of grow into that. Some people are just a basic outline. Some people just know the main ideas and go for it. But yeah, we were saying in our group earlier, the times that you regret saying something like, I really shouldn't have said that. Usually it's not in your notes.
[00:25:01] So just making sure that, you know, if you're, if your heart is checked about it, if it's in my notes and I'm not sure about it, then I'm going to leave it out. But everything I get in trouble for is not in my notes. That's where I'm at. Off the cuff comments are usually regrettable. Uh, mine's a hybrid. So there's some, especially the things I need to word the way and have, I have a cadence to it in a way that I'll remember it. I will have it manuscript, but I memorize the manuscript parts and, and the outline ones
[00:25:31] are a little bit easier to piece together. I color code as well. I use the bear app, which cross platforms from between my, um, my desktop and my iPad and all the things. And on my phone, should I decide to on the toilet? Sorry, TMI, like change something real quick right before, like during message. Sorry. Oh my God. It's so embarrassing. Um, but it just got real. It just got real guys. Apologies. Off the cuff comments. I think we were just talking about that. That was not in my notes.
[00:26:00] We can add that as well. That was a module. But it's great for searchability as well, because it allows you to put hashtags in the end and then bear will categorize all of your sermons or your teachings in a certain way. It's cool. That's awesome. I'm a hybrid. My notes are that way as well. I used to be bullet point. And I like what Haddon Robinson says. He says that the notes aren't for the listeners. They're for their, you know, for the hearers. They're for you.
[00:26:29] Your notes are just to serve what you're going to say. So whatever, whatever facilitates that and works for you, you know, use that. So, yeah. Wonderful. Yeah, absolutely. More could be said. But I want to hear from Trevor O'Keefe. So we're done. You guys, why don't you stand up, kind of wiggle around and then sit down because Trevor's going to come up. All right. Thanks for listening to this all the way to the end.
[00:26:57] If you'd like to explore any of these questions further, you'll find the resources that we mentioned along with other Expositors Collective episodes. You'll find links to them in the show notes or in the YouTube description, depending on how you're consuming this. And if this conversation helped you, consider sharing it with someone else who's learning how to teach the Bible.
[00:27:24] Maybe they're considering a call to ministry or maybe they're struggling with managing interactive group Bible study with all of the blessings and opportunities and challenges that come with the dynamics of managing a group. So anyway, I hope this episode and all that we do at Expositors Collective helps you and your friends to grow in your personal study and public proclamation of God's word.
[00:27:53] I will see you next Tuesday for episode 460. God bless.


